But if I'm paying $50/month (which is itemized on the housing bill) for the school as an ISP then I should get the same service that $50/month would get me through Comcast.
Now I'm all for locking down library and computer lab machines because those are school-owned and intended for academic purposes, but in a dorm room on a student owned computer there's nothing wrong with gaming. Schools need to either accept non-academic network use or charge less so they can say that the reduced fee brings reduced service. And in doing so, open up their cable/phone systems for competition from private ISPs.
Luckily I went to a school that believed in absolute free speech and never hindered network traffic but I heard a lot of stories from friends at schools that were less permissive.
1- i have no idea why any uni or college or any business or rental property would offer internet access and claim that they are an ISP. it's a ridiculous idea that opens themselves up to so many problems. offering an internet connection and a certain level of services to a building or campus (non educational use of the word) of buildings and offering access as a value added utility of the property is very different than being an ISP.
if i offer water as a utility to a building, and make a flat based fee for usage of the water as part of the contract, the renter is free not to use the water.
2- "there's nothing wrong with gaming" is a statement i disagree with, having known students who failed out of college due to too much mud'ing. however, i don't feel that stopping the student mud'ing was the uni's responsibility, as it isn't its responsibility not to allow the student to drink himself into a coma.
3- competition in dorm rooms for alternative phone, teevee, and internet access? i remember that being called "off campus housing". the food was better too.
4- you seem to make a connection between "absolute free speech" and unrestricted internet access. i do not see that connection in regards to allowing certain ports to be open and other ports to be closed on a gateway from a private network to a public network. if they are filtering content based upon banned words, phrases, etc, then that is something altogether different.
5- my favorite part about GTA games is driving really, really fast and then flipping over and the car catching on fire.