Most believable Batman ever. I almost believed that the presented confluence of events could occur in a world not too far from our own. One in which bullets made sparks upon hitting things.
The emotional buildup from child, to loser college age kid, to badass, to Batman was just about spot on. I liked how they clicked in the last part of the Batman persona with the closing chat with the love interest.
Oh and way to discreetly handle the tacked on love interest guys. She hardly bothered me at all. By the previews, I was afraid it was going to be yet another Batman: The Love Story. For the love of Pete people, Batman is not a love story. It is a story of personal derangement and unbending will. At no point does rescuing your girlfriend really enter into it. I'm glad they kept that part low key in this film.
Great to see Scarecrow even if he wasn't quite up to 'supervillain' snuff. Gary Oldman's Gordon was spot on. Caine wasn't my favorite Alfred, but he did his thing and it was pleasant. Morgan Freeman was wonderful. Rutger Hauer came in closer to his Buffy the Vampire Slayer performance than Blade Runner, but I like seeing the guy's face.
The Batmobile seemed like a Hummer ad to me, but the obligitory car chase scene wasn't half the movie. (Tim Burton's Batmobile just can't be beat. Damn that thing was cool.)
The fight scenes were too dark for me to tell what the hell was going on, but I didn't really go in to watch people punch eachother. Upon exiting our local non-franchised theatre, the usher -- who was not a teenager -- told me that all principals and director signed a three movie deal based on three strong treatments. So if you liked this movie, you get a Joker one next, and a Two-Face after that. Hopefully they'll leave the romantic subplots out entirely.
And by the way, if you want to see the best Batman ever put to screen, check out the original Batman: The Animated Series. At its worst it was a good kids' cartoon. At its best it was a thought provoking, character driven, artfully directed bit of afternoon entertainment. Batman Beyond seemed pretty good too, but I never saw much of it.
_______________________
Is.