I think this is a misleading statement. If all of the currently available scientific evidence is analyzed closely, the support for evolution is vastly greater. Most of this evidence is not presented to the general public very well, or understood when it is, so I can see why many people can think that they are equally valid 'theories'. Further, it's the same tired abuse of the term 'theory', which in scientific terms means a well-substantiated explanation that is held to be true by most/ all people in the field. The minor uncertainty in the term is a concession to the finity of our observations, as it's always possible that the future will yield some new observations that force us to re-evaluate our current theories. In these terms, ID is a hypothesis at best, and a poor one as it is not readily testable. It's true that we cannot ever 'prove' that the current diversity of life is due to descent with modification from one or a few common ancestors. However, that's in the same way that you can't prove that a cat with a guilty expression, in a locked, windowless room with only a goldgiraffe bowl (now sans goldgiraffe) was responsible for goldie's disappearance. You may find out later that your neighbour was testing his new teleportation device, but that certainly wouldn't be the first thing you'd think of.
I have similarly strong feelings in the department of faith, wonder, and miracles, but this isn't the place to get into that.
Irreducible complexity. That's what stops me from getting my head around the proof of evolution. I don't think I've said I think it's wrong, just that there doesn't seem to be sufficient proof for me to accept it as the ultimate explanation. And even if there was, well, tracking the question back and back and back you can't explain away the origin of space or matter other than saying it eternally is and then you still have a metaphysical question on your hands. Eventually, faith is required. For me and my life, now is as good a time as any.
And I feel sorry for you if you are anti-wonder. Wonder is a pretty powerful precursor to dreams and imagination. And faith - well, we discussed this on the board before - I don't think anyone is without faith of some kind, and what kind of relationships can you have with anyone (or yourself) without it? We all need to believe in something bigger than ourselves, that we can't see, touch, smell or taste but we know it's there. Otherwise there would be no reason to strive for anything beyond what we know and have.
As for miracles - it depends on how you define the term. I feel like I'm surrounded by them, and I try to celebrate them. Because even though my life is not even close to perfect, it's a gift and a miracle in and of itself. And it gets better every day. (maybe living in Hawaii helps)
I don't know you so I can't really guess if you're unhappy or a generally tense person or a strong rationalist - but if you aren't inclined already, take some to experience faith, wonder and miracles. They can all lead to experiencing joy.
Joy is good.