I'm glad I'm not the only one who didn't like how the GOF panned out. It was Ray tearing off that guy's face1 that killed it for me.
[1] EDIT: One year ago, to the day. I didn't even realize.
That was the moment that made me fall completely in love with the fight, and probably for the same reason it ruined it for you. It's excessively epic, and it's not how achewood normally works. If I saw that scene in a different web comic I would probably think it was cheesy. But you know... earlier this evening I was telling a friend about the freezepop song about phillipe, and how happy it makes me. Normally if someone sent me a ridiculously upbeat song about a cute cartoon otter I'd probably think it was lame, and I definitely wouldn't listen to it seven times in a row while deliriously proclaiming its awesomeness. But when cheesiness is built on a four year legacy of subtle bitterness and eerie surrealism, it becomes insanely good, in my opinion.
Not to say you're not justified in disliking it, of course. But for me the fact that I've seen ray stoned, sitting under a table and assertively measuring angles with his forearm made it that much sweeter when I saw that panel, gasped, and whispered, "He really is the son of Rodney." Happy mandible-tearing-versary, for better or for worse.