Just finished writing this play. Some of the random stories were awesome, others sad, horrifying, etc. (person who told the story noted beside)
Here's a highlights reel since none of you will get to see it:
1) a mother abuses her two children in drastically different ways (as told by the mother's adult daughter)
2) a guy goes into his ex-girlfriend's apartment using his old key, covers the mattress in a fine layer of powdered baby pablum (apparently this will stink of sour milk due to sweat and excretions), emails her family and coworkers pornographic pictures of her using her email address, and rolls her sex toys in poison ivy (as told by the guy who did it)
3) a murdered woman returns from death to let the love of her life know he doesn't need to cry anymore (as told by the woman's sister)
4) a gang member unsuccessfully attempts to drown a guy in a sewage lagoon, stabs him, douses him in gasoline but can't get the lighter to work, the guy dives into the sewage and swims through piss and shit to save his life (as told by the now ex-gang member, fresh out of prison)
5) a six year old explains to his four year old brother what evil is (as told by the two children)
6) a comic store owner talks about his personal take on the most evil moment in comics: when the Chief reveals his true nature in Doom Patrol.
7) a woman acts out a rape fantasy related to incest abuse from her past (as told by the woman)

a girl about to turn 18 comes out of the closet to her homophobic uncle (as told by the girl)
9) a monster movie fan recounts his reaction to Godzilla vs Hedorah and the fear of a monster of one's own making.
10) a man fantasizes about revenge on the man who killed his loved one (as told by the man)
11) a woman sees her former lover, who has been so badly beaten by her latest partner that she is unrecognizable (as told by the ex-girlfriend)
12) a guy is so caught up in doing drugs that he barely notices his girlfriend is dying - the solution? Do more drugs (as told by the guy)
13) the same comic book store owner reminisces about another evil moment in comics (the Leader blows up the Hulk) and reflects on the absence of clearly defined "good" and "evil" of today.
14) cut scene: a vet suffers PST and flashes back to killing a child warrior. (as told by another soldier who saw this soldier kill the boy)
Maybe now you understand why I've barely been here?
Thanks to the two members of the board who contributed stories. Apologies for the one TOUAMBIE story I didn't use - you got it in a bit too late and I already had way too many stories, but it was a good one, so thank you.