I will be able to die happy once someone explains this phenomenon to me. What the hell does it mean for someone to sound "white?"
I can pick it up within a second of listening, but I can't tell you at all what it means. This is why I don't like Nerdcore hip hop, for instance. Or "Mr Sandman."
Exactly, this is what I mean. I know I'm straying dangerously close to racism here, but Van Morrison is one of the few white men I can listen to singing and 'imagine' it coming from a black soul singer in the mould of Al Green or Marvin Gaye DESPITE the fact that his accent is in reality very different from them.
This might just be some sort of psychological thing, though. It's an undeniably widespread cliche that, true or not, black men have more musical 'soul' than white men, and so naturally we subconsciously consider this when listening to music. It's like, if I have already decided I don't like a band, it's very difficult for me to like the song, as I've already reached a subconscious conclusion and with music being so subjective it of course actually DOES change my opinion of the song for the worse.
So, when I listen to Mr Marvin Gaye, I've already reached a musical conclusion that it is going to be 'properly' soulful due to all those cliches, and this is how I consider the music from then on.
As for Van Morrison; I actually thought he was black when I first listened to him, for whatever reason, and the fact that there is another cliche backing this up (Van Morrison is one of the few white men that sounds 'soulful' enough to sound 'black') reinforces this.
Daniel, if this is true (that our subconscious feelings on music influence it hugely), then it would explain white 'lack of soul'. White middle-class American and Japanese society has always been stereotypically restrained, and this probably makes us feel that about the music. It's not just in terms of colour, of course; the Irish are stereotypically exuberant and most people I know feel Irish music sounds exuberant.
There is so much further to go with this, but it strays into racial stereotyping and I need to tidy my room so I think I will leave it for others if they want.