I think the fundamental difference of opinion here has to do with the way information is treated.
The concept of a long "Today I'm gonna" thread treats information in a manner analogous to a stream of flowing water. Since, by default, a lot of "Today, I'm gonna" information becomes obsolete after 24 hours or so, it's more like a stream of water that you can periodically dip a cup into to refill and drink from. It is not expected to digest the entirety or even the majority of this information. It is a moving flow of information that is too vast to digest and is only meant to be drawn from.
As a programmer/engineer(*) our friend TP is viewing information as a commodity to be stored and warehoused. Instead of the rushing river into which we can dip our cup anytime, he is thinking of a water tower which stores water. As such, the information has to be collated, organized, and efficiently dispensed. If the only way you got water was from a big faucet outside the water tower, you'd be overwhelmed (and likely dead). So it is with information, if you view Today I'm Gonna as a giant information warehouse. Doubly, nay, trebly so if you are a programmer/geek with a touch of the ol'
Irish Aspie, and thus a compulsive need to digest all information presented. The one giant faucet that is a single thread is overwhelming and even dangerous.
(It is here that I digress and point out to any who have not yet seen it:
http://randsinrepose.com is a fine blog from a product manager at Apple and one of the demented minds behind JerkCity (
www.jerkcity.com - NSFW NSFW NSFW). Rands in Repose is a great "How to care for your aspie nerd" blog and is a great insight into understanding their minds and making everyone happy.)
However, not all information is valid forever, and the cost of archival is often not worth the value once retrieved. Water can be stored in towers because, well, it doesn't rot. But Today I'm Gonna? information is for the most part useless because of its inherent aging and decay. The stream analogy makes it more worthwhile because then you can randomly step in and read the last page, maybe two, and step out. You can skip reading Today I'm Gonna for months on end -- Lord knows I do, because very few people are interesting and even interesting people aren't interesting all the time -- and you will lose
nothing by skipping out. Today I'm gonna is an inherently renewing, inherently decaying, inexhaustible but unstorable resource.(**) It is the dharma of existence, consumed at once in the act of its own creation, only understandable by not understanding it. You must drink from Today I'm Gonna as if it were a fountain; coming like an avalanche, pouring down a mountain.
I DON'T MIND THE SUN SOMETIMES blah blah i dont know the rest of the wooooooooooords
something something something and i smell you with my noooooose
(*)(what the fuck IS a virtual tape deck anyway? Doesn't that defeat the purpose of the advantages of tape, that it is slow but durable and info-dense?)
(**) like /b/