In the interest of fair voting, I will attempt to construct an argument for each of the nominees as MVP:
Arkabee: Sure, Arkabee isn't the most prolific poster, but when he does it is basically poetry. That, and he always has a novel viewpoint on the issues, and even when I don't agree with him, his opinions are thought-provoking. Definitely one of the most interesting people I've encountered on this board.
Bozack: Man, what can I even say about Bozack? He's the total package.
...
Okay, I'm not proud of myself. But seriously. He's funny, he's interesting, he has incredible stories, and he's a melancholy Batman. What's not to love?
Paul: Two words: picture posts. Two more words: flaming automobiles. One final word: MUSTACHE.
Side_show: Anyone good-natured enough to put up with being called "Smells" deserves your MVP vote. Seriously, though, side_show is in a lot of ways the emotional heart of the board. She's brright, honest, and genuinely caring towards a bunch of random weirdos met on a message board originally designed to discuss cartoon cats; there's something to be said for that.
Wombat: Wombat always surprises me with the sheer depth of her knowledge, both of small mammals and of non-small-mammal things. It's always a delight to discuss something with her.