Fuck all y'all Philly-haters. WHY CAN'T US?
The pitch Joe Carter hit for the home run wasn't actually a bad pitch. It was just that the slider was the only pitch Mitch seemed to be able to throw for a strike that night. So when Carter knew Mitch had to throw one over the plate, he knew to look for that pitch and where it would likely come in. And he got it, and as most big-league hitters do under circumstances where they know what's coming, he hit it far. (See also the Matt Stairs home run in game 4 vs. LA--textbook.)
That was perhaps the single worst moment of my sports fanhood, worse even than seeing the Red Wings finish off the sweep of the Caps for the Stanley Cup in person at the MCI Center. I lived in Albuqueruqe at the time, and my friends were making fun of my tremendous angst and passion for the game. Then Carter hit the home run, and nobody said a fuck*ng word to me (because they knew I'd rip their heads off).