9
« on: July 30, 2008, 06:41:26 am »
The trade is more of a fan-pleasing gesture than anything else. It's not going to make that big of a difference.
A) Considering the standings, the Angels are all but guaranteed to make the playoffs no matter if Teixera, Kotchman, or the ghost of Bengie Molina is playing first. So we're not talking about improving their odds over the long haul, we're talking about improving their odds on a per-game basis in the playoffs.
B) Both players are quality defenders, so from that perspective it's a wash.
C) Offensively, you're replacing a .287 / .327 / .448 hitter with a 283 / .390 / .512 one. Over the full season, that's big. But on a per-game basis, that's not such a monumental upgrade. I've seen the difference in the offense pegged at 4.8 runs per game versus 5 runs per game. Not that significant, especially when you consider you've just traded...
D) 3 more years of Kotchman for the playoff performance of Teixera. Again, they're guaranteed to make the playoffs, so this is all about how much better Tex makes them in the postseason.
So, yeah, it certainly helps, but I don't necessarily think it was worth the price.