I have gone completely insane shuffling my bench.
I figured out a set of nine guys who I actually want to be my set "usual" nine batters every day, barring rain-outs off-days and rest-days... and I otherwise just fuckin' cleared the deck... reconstructed my bench strictly on the lines of power and position flexibility.
I now have five different batters who are listed for multiple positions and a pitching staff constructed so that there's only one "benched" starting pitcher at any given time and so I can keep all relievers in the line-up at all times and...
The hope is that there will be never be a save that I "miss" in the shuffle.
Because here's the thing:
On a day to day basis, baseball is an insanely random series of events.
In any given game, the powerhitting catcher with no knees can luck into the back-end of a double steal and end up with a stolen base. In any given game, a banjo-hitting shortstop can get a mistake right down the middle and crank a home run.
If so much of the scoring of this particular game is going to be based on the simple accumulation of these semi-random events based as much on being there as talent relative to the rest of the major league... home runs, saves, stolen bases...
Then you gotta be in it to win it.
When your best nine AREN'T in, you gotta have the bench flexibility to at least... get them up to the plate where they MIGHT luck into a stolen base or a home run. Ditto for your pitchers and saves.
At the end of the day, every roster is gonna have about a third very average players and... they're gonna cancel each other out in terms of the averaged stats (ERA, AVG, WHIP) and stats you need to get a lot of every day such as runs and strikeouts and RBI...
When it comes to the bench of your team, you gotta just get as many guys on the "field" every night and roll the goddamn dice on their gathering the accumulated stats while their averaged stats are canceled out by everyone else's averaged stats.
This is not to say that you should just have... all multi-position players over talented players?
But there's something to be said for keeping your second-line position-flexible so that you can hold onto every goddamn one of those cheap collected statistics for the win.
I would still upgrade my back-up catcher if the opportunity presented itself.
I would still upgrade my third reliever up to a "star" if the opportunity presented itself.
I still essentially only have one actual "base stealer".
But barring injuries, my concerns are falling lower and lower on the chart.
I at least now have my "core" hitters and starters figured out and the flexibility off the bench to pick up the cheapie points on the off-days.